Mystery vs. History

Cast

• 

  Josh Radnor

  Ted Mosby

• 

  Neil Patrick Harris

  Barney Stinson

• 

  Jason Segel

  Marshall Eriksen

• 

  Alyson Hannigan

  Lily Aldrin

• 

  Cobie Smulders

  Robin Scherbatsky

• 

  Rachel Sterling

  Paula

• 

  Amber Stevens West

  Janet

• 

  Kal Penn

  Kevin Venkataraghavan

• 

  Eleanor Seigler

  Mia

• 

  Ray Wise

  Robin Scherbatsky Sr.

• 

  Drew Droege

  Waiter